Many of them felt that special anti-terror TADA court Judge P.D. Kode, who gave the sentence in Mumbai, had only proved that all Indians are equal in the eyes of law.
"I'm happy Sanjay has been sentenced. If he has done something wrong, he ought to be punished, no matter who he is. Justice should be equal for everybody," insisted Ramakant, a 32-year-old bus driver after Dutt was sentenced in the 1993 Mumbai bombings case.
Ramakant went on: "He is not the only actor we watch, somebody else will fill his place. For one person, law cannot change."
College student Manisha Pathak felt alike: "Even though he might have changed, he should still face punishment for what he did. Sanjay committed a crime and he is getting the punishment."
Pallavi Pundit, a chartered accountant, said: "Given what Sanjay has gone through, the sentence could have been reduced. But the judge knows best, and I'm sure he has given Sanjay what he deserved."
The 48-year-old actor, who has been lauded for brilliant performances in films like "Munnabhai M.B.B.S.", "Lage Raho Munnabhai", "Shootout at Lokhandwala", "Vaastav", "Parineeta" and "Mission Kashmir", has a huge fan following across the country.
Businessman Prabit Ganguly also felt that Mumbai anti-terror judge had acted wisely.
"It is good that justice is equal for everybody. If Sanjay was let off, it would have set a bad example for the Indian judiciary," he said. "Even though big bucks may be riding on him, that doesn't save him from getting the punishment."
Even Roshni Shukla, a diehard Dutt fan, echoed the majority view: "Sanjay is a very good actor. He must have changed a lot in these 14 years but why did he have to do all that in the past? I cannot imagine anybody else doing Munnabhai sequels but I guess the court has set a good example."
Only Bharti Dubey, a housewife, appeared to be sympathetic to the actor: "Sanjay was not wearing his lucky shirt today. Maybe that's the reason why he got this sentence. Moreover he has already served jail sentence before. The judge should have also taken note of that. I'm sure Sanjay will bounce back from this."
Shayan Banerjee, a school student, praised judge Kode too.
"Sanjay is a superstar whom everybody looks up to. If he was allowed to go free, then many people could have complained and raised fingers at the court. Moreover, the court has set a brilliant example. Even if you are a celebrity, you cannot be exempted from the sins that you commit."
Akash Trivedi, who does company audits, added: "I'm happy that the judge has withstood the constant pressure built up by the media, which has campaigned for Sanjay Dutt."
"This is going to be the second test for Sanjay Dutt," said Naveen Agarwal, also a businessman. "He had faced a lot of public humiliation when he went to jail for the first time. But now I'm sure though he must be dejected he will come out fine."
Factsheet on Sanjay Dutt's sentencing The following is a factsheet on Sanjay Dutt's involvement with the 1993 Mumbai bombings that led to his jailing Tuesday:
1993
January: Abu Salem, Samir Hingoraa and Baba Chavan deliver an AK-56 assault rifle and a 9 mm pistol to Sanjay Dutt at his Pali Hill home.
March 12: Mumbai serial bombings, the world's worst urban terror attack, claims 257 lives. The bombings are blamed on the underworld and Pakistani intelligence. A panicky Sanjay gives the AK to a friend to destroy it.
April 19: Arrested at Sahar Airport on arrival from Mauritius
April 27: Police record his confession
May 5: Released on bail by high court on a cash security of Rs.100,000 and directed to move designated court for regular bail
1994
July 4: Rearrested after the TADA court cancels bail
1995
Oct 18: After nearly 16 months in jail, Dutt released following Supreme Court's bail
1998
Feb 15: Marries model Rhea Pillai
2002
July 30: Mumbai police releases tapes of Dutt's conversation with a feared gangster
2003
March 7: Dutt denies having any information about gangster Chhota Shakeel
June 2: Court exempts Dutt from personal appearance till June-end, allowing him to go abroad for stage shows
2005
May 25: Father and actor-turned-politician Sunil Dutt dies
2006
Nov 28: Convicted under Arms Act but cleared of terror charges. Found guilty of possessing the 9 mm pistol without licence and AK-56 assault rifle. Granted time to surrender on a personal bond of Rs.1 million.
2007
July 31: Sentenced to six years in prison and fined Rs.25,000