Some made a mark with their sensitive themes while failing at the box office. Others were smash hits in every
which way. Here are 10 hot films of 2004:
1. "The Passion Of The Christ": A saga of sublime suffering told by Mel Gibson in excruciatingly
graphic descriptions of Jesus Christ's final days on earth as he's taken to the cross to be nailed. Conveniently
enough, this work of timeless art and over-brimming heart was sneeringly dismissed as a paean to masochism
and sadism. What Gibson does in his masterly study of pain, suffering, redemption and atonement is to
resurrect the spirit of humanism in ways that cinema had forgotten.
2. "Morning Raga": Shabana Azmi once again blew the screen apart with yet another powerhouse
performance. This time she played a retired, mourning Carnatic singer who's pulled out of a past tragedy by two
vivacious students (Prakash Rao and Perizaad Zoarbian). Thematically, Mahesh Dattani's was by far the most
powerful film of the year.
Bringing together various layers and levels of cross-cultural images, fusing raga sounds with modern elements,
"Morning Raga" eminently took on the age-old conflict between tradition and change.
3. "Yuva": The most underrated and misunderstood film of the year, "Yuva" brought together the lives of
three young men in search of truth and motivation. Their lives crisscrossed on Kolkata's Howrah Bridge in ways
that reminded some critics of Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu's Spanish-language film "Amores Perros". But to
punish "Yuva" for adapting Inarrritu's narrative format was to equate the specific work with art for the genre.
Expertly cut, and with stand-out performances by Abhishek Bachchan, Kareena Kapoor, Vivek Oberoi, Rani
Mukherjee and Sonu Sood, "Yuva" is a film that begs to be revisited.
4. "Dev": Govind Nihalani's dark and ominous film inspired by the Gujarat holocaust crept up on us with
force, compelling us to think when we would rather go to the movies just to have fun. The dialogue between a
communal and a non-communal cop played by Om Puri and Amitabh Bachchan was inter-cut by a tender love
story between two Muslim youngsters, Fardeen Khan and Kareena Kapoor, torn apart by the savagery of
communal riots. While gripping our senses the film raised grim issues like the hand of police in instigating
communal animosity.
5. "Maqbool": Vishal Bhardwaj's relentlessly dark tale of ambition, lust, crime and retribution was
inspired by Shakespeare's "Macbeth". Shakespeare met Ram Gopal Varma in "Maqbool" and then they both
met a stirring nemesis in a swoop of echoes that reverberated across a tale that was both shocking and
redemptive. Three very strong central performances by Pankaj Kapur, Tabu and Irfan Khan held the powerful plot
together. You couldn't take your eyes off these tainted souls.
6. "Khamosh Pani": So what if they spoke in Punjabi in Pakistani director Sabiha Sumar's big-little
film? They spoke Latin and Hebrew in "The Passion Of The Christ", didn't they? It didn't make a jot of difference
to the film's universal appeal. Taking us into the life of a historically challenged woman (Kirron Kher) who finds
her present obviated by her past, the film portrayed the trauma of the partition without actually reliving the
historical accident visually. Kirron Kher's charged performance brought a whole ethos to life. The physical and
emotional details were impeccable.
7. "Mughal-e-Azam": The colour-revised edition of K. Asif's time-less romance was surcharged with
emotions soaked and saturated in the finest traditions of romantic cinema. Cynics said the experiment with
renewed glory won't work. But what do you know! Madhubala looked doubly glamorous in colour. Naushad's
music, newly re-recorded in Dolby stereophonic added to the lure of nostalgia. And the chaste Urdu dialogues
which many experts thought would go right above today's youngsters' heads had them spellbound. Lesson
number one - never underestimate the audience. Lesson number two - they still prefer Madhubala to
Mallika.
8. "Monster": If one performance can hold a film together, then let's all join hands to celebrate Charlize
Theron's theme-defining performance as a lesbian hooker in this relentlessly dark and disturbing film that
graphically portrays the degradation of a social outcast. Theron transforms herself for a performance that
screams for attention...and gets it.
9. "Swades": Ashutosh Gowariker's elegiac back-to-the-roots tale of patriotism unfurled like a lingering
flag. So what if the film didn't make as many waves as it was expected to? "Swades" offers us a chance to sink
into a comforting level of sincerity.
A complete absence of cynicism gives Ashutosh Gowariker's film a feeling of fresh idealism, singularly lacking
in films today. Then there's Shah Rukh Khan in by far the best performance of his career. Gowariker's "Swades"
had all the solutions.
10. "Veer-Zaara": Yash Chopra's purported love legend didn't quite touch legendary heights. But on the
thematic level the story of man who waits for two decades to get back his love was as poignant as its gets. The
poetry, music and romance of Yash Chopra's cinema were all there in this engrossing film about the unfinished
business of love.
And the other notables: Sudhir Mishra's "Chameli", Revathi's "Phir Milenge", M.F Husain's "Meenaxi: A Tale Of
3 Cities", Gurinder Chadha's "Bride & Prejudice", Pamela Rooks' "Dance Like A Man", Rituparno Ghosh's
"Raincoat" and Farhan Akhtar's "Lakshya".
Thursday, December 30, 2004 16:49 IST