What is Bollywood's 'Jurm'?

What is Bollywood's 'Jurm'?
Monday, February 21, 2005 18:42 IST
By Santa Banta News Network
Is the Hollywood era in Bollywood waning?

After a string of recent original films took audiences into uncharted territories, Indian audiences seem unwilling to patronise those who tread the beaten path of Hollywood remakes sprinkled with song and dance numbers and gallons of melodrama served up on a new platter.

Warnings from international film producers and high-profile lawsuits have hitherto had little or no impact on the age-old practice of picking up Hollywood plots.

Now, all this seems to be changing.

"Where lawsuits and warnings did not work, the box-office diktat will," said a trade observer.

Take the case of Vikram Bhatt, who made his reputation with remakes like "Fareb" ("Unlawful Entry"), "Ghulam" ("On The Waterfront"), "Kasoor" ("Jagged Edge"), "Raaz" ("What Lies Beneath") and "Awaara Pagal Deewana" ("The Whole Nine Yards").

Then "Elaan" bombed and his latest offering "Jurm" is threatening to go the same way.

Audiences are showing no enthusiasm for the film, starring Bobby Deol, Lara Dutta, Gul Panag and Milind Soman, that released Friday even as they continue to queue up for Sanjay Leela Bhansali's very unique "Black".

Filmmakers like Bhansali, Ram Gopal Varma, Ashutosh Gowarikar, Madhur Bhandarkar, Farhan Akhtar and many more have provided Indian viewers with alternatives for Hollywood-inspired films.

In Bollywood over the years, many films were launched on the whims and fancies of producers who aim at just one thing - to double the returns on investments within a year.

Now the box-office verdict is - no more lifting stories scene-by-scene from Hollywood hits, or borrowing regional languages films or making adaptations of popular Hindi old-timers.

Bollywood insiders speak about scriptwriters who "specialise" in plagiarism - in fact they are ready with their version of a Hollywood movie the day it is released.

In search of material, while some visit film festivals all over the world, others watch old movies on television.

"How do you expect writers to spend months to come up with an original script, only to find that some fly-by-night copycat writer managed to sell his for a high price?" Trade Guide editor asks.

According to Anurag Kashyap, scriptwriter of "Shool" and "Satya", writers are paid less than Rs. 100,000 for what is called "developing a story". After it is approved, the writer gets the go ahead.

"We are paid only 2.5 to 3.5 percent of the budget," says Kashyap.

The Indian film industry requires three new scripts daily to make films at the current rate, says Bollywood financier Bharat Shah.

This is probably the reason for rampant plagiarism.

"Attention is paid to the costume designer, the actor, but not to the writer, the film's backbone," said industry watcher Komal Nata.

Copycats rule the entertainment industry, giving stiff competition to original players by quoting lower rates.

After films, music is the second biggest casualty.

DJs are finding their remix numbers recorded and replayed, event managers are seeing their once-exclusive interiors replicated everywhere and original audio and video shop owners are facing tough competition from sellers of fake tapes.

Plagiarism, or "inspiration" as Bollywood prefers calling it, has apparently always existed.

According to one trade observer, Mehboob Khan's masterpiece "Mother India", in 1957 had shades of Pearl S. Buck's "The Good Earth".

In defence, veteran writer-director Mahesh Bhatt says: "When you take an idea and route it through the Indian heart, it changes entirely. You cannot pin a person down on an idea."

The last word on the subject, however, will lie with the box-office.
Varun Dhawan Unveils First Poster of 'Nain Matakka' Featuring Keerthy Suresh!

Varun Dhawan's upcoming film Baby John is already creating waves in the entertainment world. The latest buzz surrounds the highly anticipated track "Nain Matakka," and the excitement reached new heights when Varun shared the

Friday, November 22, 2024
'Agni' Trailer Unveiled: A Tribute to Firefighters' Bravery and Sacrifice!

The much-anticipated trailer for Agni, directed by National Award-winning filmmaker Rahul Dholakia, was released on Thursday, offering a gripping look into the world of firefighters, their bravery, and the sacrifices they make to protect

Friday, November 22, 2024
Sara Ali Khan Shares Fun BTS Moments from Ad Shoot, Invites Fans to Let Their Spirits Soar!

Bollywood actress Sara Ali Khan recently took to Instagram to share a delightful behind-the-scenes (BTS) glimpse from her latest advertisement shoot, revealing her cheerful mood and creative spirit. In a playful and heartwarming post, Sara shared a video

Friday, November 22, 2024
Kartik Aaryan Enjoys Quality Time with 'Sea, Sand, and Sun' at IFFI Goa!

Bollywood heartthrob Kartik Aaryan, who is currently in Goa for the prestigious International Film Festival of India (IFFI) and Filmazaar, took a moment to unwind and connect with nature. The actor shared a series of serene pictures on his Instagram, showcasing

Friday, November 22, 2024
Shehnaaz Gill Starts Shooting for Punjabi Film: A New Journey Begins!

Actress and social media sensation Shehnaaz Gill is all set to embark on a new chapter in her career, as she commences shooting for her upcoming Punjabi film. The actress shared her excitement with her fans on Instagram, marking this milestone

Friday, November 22, 2024
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT