Is 'Black' a copy?

Is 'Black' a copy?
Wednesday, February 23, 2005 17:02 IST
By Santa Banta News Network
Now here is a question filmmaker Sanjay Leela Bhansali seriously needs to answer. Is Black his original work or is it a blatant copy of William Gibson's double-Oscar winning classic 'The Miracle Worker'?

The 1962 Hollywood flick stars Anne Bancroft in the lead role of an instructor, who teaches blind and deaf Helen Keller played by Patty Duke.

The pangs and traumas Bhansali's little Michelle goes through are visibly similar to Patty's superb portrayal, whereas, Big B fills into Bancroft's shoes to accomplish the nearly impossible task of teaching this physically challenged girl.

Call it a mere coincidence, as Debraj's Alzheimer makes his ambitious task a wee bit more daunting; the female teacher in 'The Miracle Worker' suffers from half blindness.

So, is India's slickest film ever a plagiarised work or a sheer inspiration from the true story of Hellen Keller, rent a DVD and decide for yourself.
Sunny Kaushal, Nimrat Kaur, Medha Shankr Unite for a Quirky Detective Comedy!

The latest buzz in Bollywood is all about an upcoming quirky detective comedy featuring Sunny Kaushal

Thursday, January 23, 2025
Why Kareena Kapoor Khan Didn't Accompany Saif Ali Khan to the Hospital After Knife Attack!

Fresh details surrounding the shocking knife attack on Bollywood actor Saif Ali Khan have surfaced

Thursday, January 23, 2025
Boman Irani's Directorial Debut 'The Mehta Boys' Premieres on Prime Video This February!

Acclaimed Bollywood actor Boman Irani is stepping into the director’s chair for the first time with his highly

Thursday, January 23, 2025
Aaman Devgan and Rasha Thadani speak out on Nepotism in Bollywood on In The Ring with Filmfare!

Director Abhishek Kapoor joined forces with debutants Aaman Devgan and Rasha Thadani in Azaad

Thursday, January 23, 2025
Jackie Shroff talks about the birds from the set of Amazon MX Player's Chidiya Udd!

Amazon MX Player, Amazon's free video streaming service, has recently unveiled its highly anticipated crime

Thursday, January 23, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT