Is 'Black' a copy?

Is 'Black' a copy?
Wednesday, February 23, 2005 17:02 IST
By Santa Banta News Network
Now here is a question filmmaker Sanjay Leela Bhansali seriously needs to answer. Is Black his original work or is it a blatant copy of William Gibson's double-Oscar winning classic 'The Miracle Worker'?

The 1962 Hollywood flick stars Anne Bancroft in the lead role of an instructor, who teaches blind and deaf Helen Keller played by Patty Duke.

The pangs and traumas Bhansali's little Michelle goes through are visibly similar to Patty's superb portrayal, whereas, Big B fills into Bancroft's shoes to accomplish the nearly impossible task of teaching this physically challenged girl.

Call it a mere coincidence, as Debraj's Alzheimer makes his ambitious task a wee bit more daunting; the female teacher in 'The Miracle Worker' suffers from half blindness.

So, is India's slickest film ever a plagiarised work or a sheer inspiration from the true story of Hellen Keller, rent a DVD and decide for yourself.
Rashmika Mandanna Unveils Bold First Look from 'Mysaa' -Her Fiercest Role Yet!

Popular pan-India star Rashmika Mandanna has officially dropped the curtain on her next big project

Friday, June 27, 2025
Alia Bhatt Channels Rekha's Timeless Glamour in Silsila-Inspired Look at Umrao Jaan Screening!

Bollywood’s beloved fashionista and powerhouse performer Alia Bhatt once again proved her style prowess

Friday, June 27, 2025
Neeru Bajwa Deletes All 'Sardaar Ji 3' Posts Amid Controversy Over Hania Aamir's Casting!

The Punjabi horror-comedy Sardaar Ji 3 has found itself at the center of a heated controversy following the

Friday, June 27, 2025
WAR 2 to have a Global IMAX Release in theatres!

YRF’s blockbuster Spy Universe’s most anticipated action spectacle of the year WAR 2 will play exclusively

Friday, June 27, 2025
Sonakshi Sinha's ‘Nikita Roy' Release Postponed to Amid Screen Battle!

The much-anticipated supernatural thriller Nikita Roy, headlined by Sonakshi Sinha, has officially

Friday, June 27, 2025